Paranoia-A Critique

Paranoia-A Critique

We have entered the third millennium through a gate of fire. If today, after the horror of 11 September, we see better, and we see further — we will realize that humanity is indivisible.New  threats  make  no  distinction  between  races,  nations  or  regions.  A  new  insecurity  has entered every mind, regardless of wealth or status. A deeper awareness of the bonds that bind us all — in pain as in prosperity — has gripped young and old.

–Kofi Annan

The 9/11 attacks are considered the biggest massacre in the history of humanity. A thousand people dead  in  a  matter  of  minutes. And  yet  most  people  do  not  consider  this  as  the  only  parameter  to consider it the biggest massacre in the history. Today as an aftermath of the attack, multi-trillion dollars  have  been  blown  into  the  war  against  terrorism.  It  has  pushed  the  world  to  a  brink  of complete  economic  chaos.  It  has  resulted  in  a  kind  of  victory  that  the Al-Qaeda  and  Osama  bin
Laden had never planned for.

Though, an economic chaos is not the only major consequence. As Kofi Annan had once stated, it gave the world a common enemy. People now realise that extremists have no boundaries; they can go  to  any  limits  to  get  what  they  want. And  as  later  events  have  unfolded,  it  has  been  proved. Countries like India and the United States of America have come together to fight this malice. It has improved international relations. Governments have changed policies drastically. The 9/11 attacks for  surely  have  changed  the  face  of  the  world.  However,  Mr.  Kofi Annan  has  taken  an  a  very optimistic view to the whole event.

Let me share an anecdote. I was browsing through the internet and I came across a joke. It was about  a  Muslim  mother  talking  to  her  friend  about  her  terrorist  children.  The  punchline  has  the woman sighing, “They blow up so fast”. It is a pitch perfect parody of every mothers lament that children grow up so fast. One day, I was reading an article which said, “Sniff the armpit of America
as the 9/11 decade comes close to an end, and the odour is unmistakably fear”.

Such article over the internet prompted me to read more into the general psyche of people post 9/11. And what I found was undoubtedly a complete contrast of what Mr. Kofi Annan had quoted. Let me share  another  anecdote  at  this  point.  In  2001,  after  the  attacks,  a  Virgin Atlantic Airways  flight travelling  from  Europe  to  LA  saw  an  incident.  Somewhere  over  Canada,  the  attendant  noticed  a suspicious looking object behind a seat. Immediately the cabin erupted in panic and an emergency
landing took place. The passengers were evacuated and a bomb squad was sent in to analyse this ’suspicious-looking object’. As it turned out, it was just a cell phone!

On the 11th of September, 2001, terrorist did more than just destroy two buildings. They altered the human  psyche.  And  the  details  are  telling.  In  the  years  immediately  after  2001,  American pharmacists reported a 25% increase in the sale of anti-anxiety drugs. The University of Michigan, Ann-Harbour conducted a study in the months immediately following the attacks, on some 1000
odd people and found that 49% of the respondents had their sense of security and safety shaken. And some 60% have difficulty in sleeping. Harvard conducted a similar study which showed that 57% people had taken steps to protect themselves, such as taking precaution in opening mails and avoiding public events.

These  figures  are  certainly  shocking  in  the  very  least,  if  not  depressing.  Such  an  over-reaction shows just how fearful ordinary people are. There is nothing wrong with feeling fear. Fear is one of the most basic emotions; and in way one of the most important ones. It is like pain. No body likes pain, but is the most important part of a natural alarm system that has ensured human existence and survival for a very long time. But when this fear starts to take over our lives, in a way, starts to control our lives, it throws the world into perpetual disorder and chaos.

To illustrate the severity of this constant psychological fear state, doctors and scientists across The USA  have  noticed  changing  blood  patterns  among  people.  The  vessels  close  to  skin  are  slowly constricting, so that more blood is available to the large muscles. This is an effect of constant fear, triggering the natural response to run at the sight of fear.

Post  9/11,  we  constantly  hear  Indian  students  being  beaten  up  in  foreign  countries,  being  called ’Pakis’. People are getting anxious based on the skin colour. Defence agencies all across the world have  started  introducing  new  policies  that  are  bordering  paranoia.  Some  might  argue  that  this paranoia is justified. But terrorists and insurgents are using this paranoia (‘Perception Management and  Psychological  Warfare’  PSYWAR,  as  this  kind  of  guerilla  warfare  is  termed)  to  further aggravate the alienation of the people in terrorism affected areas like India.

Agreed  that  the  general  level  of  anxiety  should  ease  with  time.  But  sparse  incidents,  as  are witnessed  all  over  India  through  the  past  years,  months  and  weeks,  has  further  aggravated  the anxiety  levels  in  people.  Just  recently,  when  Ahmedabad  was  on  a  high  alert,  I  remember  my parents calling up, anxious that I not go out of campus. The small blasts that we have witnessed all over  India,  might,  to  some  extent  be  considered  small  as  compared  to  the  9/11  attack,  but collectively they have a very severe effect. Just recently it was reported in California, a man opened an envelope and a powdery substance spilled out. He alerted the flight attendant. Once the plane lands, FBI rushes in to investigate. The powdery substance turned out to be confetti powder. People are  being  alienated;  governments  are  imposing  more  and  more  ‘unavoidable  inconveniences’  in everyday life.

Mr. Kofi Annan shared a very optimistic view of the human nature. When words like Islamophobia are coined, it in no way helps in uniting people against a common faceless enemy. Coincidentally, he himself was quoted as saying, “When the world is compelled to coin a new term to take account of the increasingly widespread bigotry, that is sad and troubling development.”

Leave a Reply

Connect with Facebook

*